top of page

Frequently Asked Questions

For the unquenchably curious, here's a little more information about kung fu and myself. If you have further questions, feel free to get in touch with me via the contact form of this website. If, however, you're looking for general info about my approach to life and martial arts, the best place to go is the blog on this website.

01

02

You say you have a 7th duan black belt in kung fu. I thought Chinese martial arts didn't use a belt system for rank?

​


The belt system was applied to Chinese martial arts publicly in 1998 by the Chinese Wushu Association, but individual schools and sects have been using it longer than that. Shaolin temple has also has its own belt system, and the Yang family apply a belt system to their style of Taijiquan. From the Wikipedia page on rank in martial arts comes the official breakdown of the black belt ranks according to the CWA:

"Beginning Level: So-called basic duans for students with some years of experience.

 

1. Qingying—yi duan: Bronze/blue Eagle

2. Yinying—er duan: Silver Eagle

3. Jinying—san duan: Gold Eagle

 

Intermediate Level: Middle-level duans are for wushu students/coaches who are able to teach and have between 5 and 10 years wushu coaching experience depending on level applied for. Starting from 5th Duan, there has to be proof of a scientific work in wushu research, i.e. publications, DVD, training of Duanwei examined students. Six Duanwei can use the title of Master as this is the highest technical grade.

 

4. Qinghu—si duan: Bronze/blue Tiger

5. Yinhu—wu duan: Silver Tiger

6. Jinhu—liu duan: Gold Tiger

 

Advanced Level:Advanced level is only awarded to very experienced masters with excellent reputation in Wushu. The person awarded such a Duan is officially allowed to call himself "Grand Master".

 

7. Qinglong—qi duan: Bronze/blue Dragon

8. Yinlong—ba duan: Silver Dragon

9. Jinlong—jiu duan: Gold Dragon"

 

Generally, there will be anywhere from 4 to 10 coloured belts to earn prior to black belt level. And usually, belts terminate at 9, rather than 10, like the Korean systems. 

 

What is the connection between spirituality and martial arts? Are you a Buddhist?

I am not a Buddhist, although I have studied Buddhism at university and practised some techniques from esoteric Buddhism in the past.

 

The relationship between martial arts and spirituality is a historic and cultural one, similar to the west, whose (almost extinct) medieaval martial arts grew up intertwined with codes of chivalry and tectonic religious knightly orders.

 

Shaolin is a Buddhist temple, and their philosophy is reflected in their martial arts. Likewise, mt Wudang, the (possibly mythical) home of Taiji is a Taoist holy place, and the so called 'big 3' internal martial arts (Taijiquan, Xingyi and Baguazhang) are heavilly informed by Taoist belief. 

 

But to practise, say, Baguazhang, which is based on the 8 trigrams of the Yi King, is not the same as declaring yourself a Taoist. 

 

A muddy area is the practise of various Qi Gongs, like the microcosmic orbit. If you perform the microcosmic orbit, are you now a practising Taoist? What about the lesser enlightenments of Li and Kan? Ultimately, I believe it depends on how you frame your practise conceptually. For me, performing these Qi Gong routines doesn't entail any kind of denominational religious truth -- it's just one set of tools to acheive a universal spiritual experience, or get closer to fulfilling our human potential (which I do believe includes various 'magical' powers, such as the ability to control dreams, or acheive heightened strength, speed, etc.)

 

In the interest of full disclosure, I am a tantic adept of the Nath Sampradeya and an experienced practitioner of Taoist Qi Gong, but religiously I am agnostic. I know plenty of accomplished martial artists from a variety of religious traditions, many more who, like me, are agnostic, and even more who profess to no spiritual beliefs whatsoever. With the exception of one extremely fundamental baptist, none of them have had any problems with the practise of Qi Gong.

03

Is Kung Fu effective?

Kung Fu is really a catch all term for Chinese martial arts, and as such refers to a multitude of styles; hundreds, perhaps even thousands. So to ask whether Kung Fu is effective for fighting is a huge oversimplification. Some styles are sport styles, and as such have a pedigree in sporting competition: Sanda, San Shou, and Shuai Jiao are the most common styles, but these terms also refer to rule sets under which stylists from more traditional styles compete. And many of these traditional styles have competed on Lei Tai (a raised platform that fighters from various styles of Kung Fu compete on). Hung Ga, Pak Mei and Baji are common examples. Other arts, like Pao Chui and Xingyiquan have a history of military and mercenary practise. There are many practitioners of various Kung Fu systems who like to claim that Chinese martial arts are the greatest form of close quarter combat available, but this is nonsense. In fact, the constant repression of martial arts at home by a slew of governments in China, mixed with the commercialism of some modern teachers, has damaged Kung Fu's reputation.

It is also true that Chinese martial arts have a long history of non-combative facets: there are performance arts: Chinese Opera, and modern Wushu both fall into this category.

Providing you have some potential and a realistic will to fight, there are 2 ingredients in any form of martial arts training that simply cannot be done without:

1 - Realistic techniques: if you want to do well in real fighting, your style must contain simple, effective, techniques that you can pull off under pressure and regularly succeed with. That's not to say that it can't include more unexpected maneouvers, but there must be a realistic core of basic techniques. Things like jabs, crosses, front kicks and throws. Sport arts in particular have realistic techniques. However, it is also important to make sure the techniques you are training equip you for the type of combat in which you are expecting to be engaged. Training boxing alone will ill-equip you for MMA. Training MMA will be of limited use if attacked with a blade. And, as the old saying goes, never take a knife to a gun fight (sorry, Escrimadors).

2 - Realistic training: the best techniques in the world aren't going to help you unless you practise them on other fighters of equal and greater skill than yourself in a completely non-compliant way. For this reason, it is important to engage in full contact sparring if you want to ensure that your martial art is effective.

 

Of course, there are other important factors that contribute to fighting skill -- various drills, different types of conditioning, a study of psychology, strategy, and tactics -- but it's teh above two points that most traditional martial artists fall down on. If you include them in your training, then your martial art (Kung Fu or otherwise) will likely be formidable.

 

bottom of page